no way

Mine was my finger. At one point I gave myself an enema to see what that felt like (yeah, seems weird but I tried it just to experiment). Some years later, with a college girlfriend, we were having sex, one night, and she did something she had not done before, she started fingering my ass and licking it. The way she did it just nearly drove me crazy with pleasure and I returned the favor for her. I didn't do anything like that again until I was married (to someone else). My wife was doing a hand job on me, one day, and I asked her to stick her finger in me. She smiled, said "OK", lubed her finger with lotion and did it. She has done that again, occasionally, when she has done hand jobs on me. I love having her finger in me.

I guess it was my finger. Later I progressed to pens, the handle of a razor, a butt plug and even some plastic beads on a string (BenWa balls?).

It was my finger first one then two. Now I've graduated to butt plugs dildoes and anything that won't harm and feels good.
barebottomboy

Finger First.

When I was a young boy, I carved a penis shaped probe from a piece of hickory wood. SENSATIONAL!

Now I have a collection of Vibrators, Dildos, Dongs, and Butt Plugs.

Finger also.

Also a finger but not mine

my finger then a dildoe

A finger then the handle of my hair brush (it was a small tapered handle)

mine was a cock. i guess you can say i cut to the chase.

wow.... you didnt waste any time did u? hehe

mine was a 9" dildo.. and oh my fuck i loved it.

the only problem now is that i can never find something big enough to stretch my ass wide open.

i really want my ass torn so wide.

who can help me.

maybe 2 cocks in my ass at the same time. ...mmmmm

A pen covered with a condom, I was 13 and didn't have lube. Then I got my boyfriend at the time to buy me anal beads.

my finger

my finger

The first thing was an enema insert. The last was the biggest carrot in the bag, stem end first.

First thing was my finger then another persons finger and then i tried a thin Dildo

my finger then a hairbrush handel

The first thing I put in my bum was my finger and i still love fingering my tight bum when I shower.

my husbands cock mmmmmmmmmmm

my finger

finger, broom handle, then dildos

Must be the least kinkiest on this site - only had a colonic irrigation straw SO that basically means I'm still an ass virgin and planning on staying that way.

My finger. From there a bullet vibe. Then small dildo. Now I regularly use several dildos, prostate messagers and a medium plug.

..and it was about 30mins ago!!

My finger

My finger

Oh man, I'd seen that you were the las poster on this thread from main page before you get into the forum & I thought to myself "No way, ya couldn't have got a guitar up there!!" LOL. Seriously, thanks for replying!!

first my fingers and then dildos...from what i can remember all started at 15 or 16...